| First Name | Last Name | High School | College Commit |
| ANTHONY | AGOSTINELLI | KINGS PARK | COLLEGE OF SI |
| NIKO | ANTINORO | SACHEM EAST | WELLS |
| RJ | AZARIEH | ST JOHN THE BAPTIST | NEW HAVEN |
| EVAN | BASCHNAGEL | CHAMINADE | MAINE |
| MICHAEL | BENEDICT | FORT PIERCE | EASTERN FLORIDA |
| BRYAN | BIRKL | FARMINGDALE | WEST CONN |
| TOMMY | BRESSMER | LUHI | ST PETERS |
| NOLAN | BRITT | CONNETQUOT | STAC |
| SEAN | BRITT | SOUTHSIDE | TOWSON |
| JACK | CASTILLO | MASSAPEQUA | PLATTSBURGH |
| BRADY | CLARK | BAYPORT BLUE POINT | ST JOHNS |
| JAMES | COATS | KELLENBERG | GORDON |
| JACK | COSTELLO | PAT-MED | NEW PLATZ |
| CONNOR | DEBLASI | COLLEGIATE | ARMY |
| MATT | DIEGUEZ | CHAMINADE | FORDHAM |
| CONNOR | DONG | HUNTER | U OF CHICAGO |
| MIKEY | DUDA | MINEOLA | MISACORDIA |
| ERIK | DUIGNAN | CONNETQUOT | ADELPHI |
| JAMES | EDEN | MACARTHUR | ADELPHI |
| EJ | ETTINGER | KINGS PARK | NEW HAVEN |
| RICKY | FASITTA | WEST BABYLON | PLATTSBURGH |
| JOE | FRAZZETTA | ARCHBISHOP MOLLOY | NEW HAVEN |
| ESTEBAN | GARCIA | POLY PREP | BOSTON COLLEGE |
| TRISTAN | GATCHALIAN | ESM | MARYWOOD |
| MATT | GERARDI | HUNTINGTON | ALBRIIGHT |
| ALEX | GOLDSTEIN | BELLMORE JFK | WEST CONN |
| MATT | GRAZIOSE | HEWLITT | CEN CONN ST |
| JAKE | GRIFFIN | HOLY REDEEMER | TENNESSEE |
| PETER | HARALAMBIDIS | MINEOLA | CMSV |
| TJ | HARRINGTON | SEAFORD | OSWEGO |
| AIDAN | HEALY | CHAMINADE | NAVY |
| TIM | HENNING | WANTAGH | BINGHAMTON |
| KURT | JOHNSON | ST ANTHONYS | SUNY POLY |
| BILLY | KIND | SEAFORD | ADELPHI |
| RYAN | KNIERMANN | WESTHAMPTON BEACH | NEW PALTZ |
| NICK | KOSTULIAS | MINEOLA | NEW PALTZ |
| PATRICK | KREMPASKY | SACHEM EAST | BRIDGEPORT |
| CHARLIE | LEO | MEPHAM | SUNY POLY |
| JACK | MCDONALD | BAYPORT BLUE POINT | KINGS |
| MICHAEL | MUGNO | ST ANTHONYS | CATHOLIC |
| PAUL | NAPOLITANO | KELLENBERG | HIGH POINT |
| PETER | NENADICH | ST FRAN PREP | QUEENS |
| ERIK | PAULSEN | MASSAPEQUA | STONY BROOK |
| MATT | QUEEN | POLY PREP | PEPPERDINE |
| JOE | RICHETTI | SACHEM EAST | NEW PALTZ |
| RAF | RODGERS | BISHOP ESTACE PREP | LEHIGH |
| DYLAN | ROSENBERG | WHEATLEY | OSWEGO |
| ESTEBAN | SALAZAR | LYNBROOK | MULENBERG |
| ANTHONY | SCARABINO | CONNETQUOT | ALBANY |
| JACK | SCHULZ | OCEANSIDE | MOLLOY |
| JACOB | SHEHATA | ST JOHN THE BAPTIST | SUNY POLY |
| NATHAN | SICA | PLAINVIEW | DREW |
| LIAM | STEMMLER | BAYPORT BLUE POINT | FDU-FLORHAM |
| MIKE | SWEENEY | CHAMINADE | HOFSTRA |
| JAYDEN | TANG | COUNCIL ROCK | FDU |
| ZAINE | TONESKE | CHRISTIAN BROTHERS | ST JOHNS |
| CHRIS | TRIOLO | KINGS PARK | BROCKPORT |
| CRISTINO | TUFANO | BABYLON | GEORGE WASHINGTON |
| ANTHONY | VACCA | ST JOHN THE BAPTIST | FARMINGDALE |
| MIKE | VILARDI | MASSAPEQUA | QUEENS |
| CHARLIE | WEST | WARD MELVILLE | UCONN |
| JOE | YOVINO | DIVISON | ELON |
| 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2007 | 2008 | 2009 | 2010 | 2011 | 2012 | 2013 | 2014 | 2015 | 2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 | 2020 | 2021 | 2022 |
| First Name | Last Name | High School | College Commit |
| NICK | AMENDOLARA | LOCUST VALLEY | DEAN |
| FABIAN | APICELLA | SCHOLARS ACADEMY | NEW PALTZ |
| JOE | ARIOLA | CHAMINADE | WAKE FOREST |
| DYLAN | BANNER | PLAINVIEW-JFK | ALBANY |
| ANTHONY | BULLA | SACHEM EAST | FARMINGDALE |
| RYAN | CALLAGHAN | KINGS PARK | STAC |
| JAMES | CAMACHO | ST DOMS | WELLS |
| MICHAEL | CAMARDI | SYOSSETT | FARMINGDALE |
| JASON | CAMPO | ST JOHN THE BAPTIST | STONY BROOK |
| JOHN CARLO | CANGRO | OLD BRIDGE | LYNN |
| JOE | CAPANO | AVON OLD FARMS | TRINITY |
| KYLE | CHASE | ST JOHN THE BAPTIST | ST JOHNS |
| JARED | COHEN | BYRAM HILLS | ARMY |
| TJ | COX | MINEOLA | FARMINGDALE |
| DOMINICK | CREMA | ST JOHN THE BAPTIST | STAC |
| JAYLEN | CRUZ | HOLY CROSS | SOUTHERN CT |
| DIOSCAR | CUELLO | LONGWOOD | SUFFOLK CC |
| DOMINICK | DIMARTINO | ST JOSEPHS BY THE SEA | FELICIAN |
| JOHN | DOWNING | CHAMINADE | SETON HALL |
| PETE | FASIGLIONE | IONA PREP | NOTRE DAME |
| LUKE | FILLIPPI | PORT JEFFERSON | ALBANY |
| ANDREW | FINGLETON | SOUTHSIDE | BINGHAMTON |
| AEDAN | FORDE | ST JOHN THE BAPTIST | NEW HAVEN |
| JACOB | GALAZ | NEWFIELD | STAC |
| ZACH | GANCA | BELLMORE | RUTGERS-FLORHAM |
| DOMINICK | GATTI | CHAMINADE | NEW HAVEN |
| JJ | GATTI | CHAMINADE | DAYTON |
| LUCA | GOLDFLAM | ST DOMS | WILLIAMS |
| CHRIS | GOOHS | SMITHTOWN EAST | MANHATTANVILLE |
| DYLAN | GOVIN | LONGWOOD | PLATTSBURGH |
| GARRET | GRATHWOHL | MATTITUCK | NEW PALTZ |
| MATT | GUIDO | SACHEM EAST | LYCOMING |
| JOE | HACKEL | NEWFIELD | STEVENSON |
| ROCCO | HALL | LONGWOOD | MANHATTANVILLE |
| JAKE | HALL | LONGWOOD | MANHATTANVILLE |
| STEVE | HARDIMAN | KELLENBERG | BENTLEY |
| JOE | HAUSER | ST FRANCIS | NORTHEASTERN |
| PAT | HEBER | GARDEN CITY | BENTLEY |
| ANDREW | HEIDERSTADT | CHAMINADE | MARITIME |
| KENNY | HIRSHFIELD | KELLENBERG | NEW HAVEN |
| BAYRAM | HOT | ARCHBISHOP MOLLOY | MARIST |
| EVAN | HUGHES | NEWFIELD | RUSSELL SAGE |
| LOU | IANNACCHINO | CENTER MORICHES | PLATTSBURG |
| JOSH | INDEK | PLAINVIEW-JFK | BROCKPORT |
| SEAN | JOST | SMITHTOWN WEST | JOHN JAY |
| JIMMY | KEENAN | IONA PREP | ST JOHNS |
| AIDAN | KUEFNER | SEAFORD | CLARKSTON |
| JOHN | KWIATKOWSKI | KELLENBERG | MANHATTAN |
| JACOB | LEE | SYOSSET | ADELPHI |
| SHANE | LINETT | CALHOUN | NEW PALTZ |
| ANTHONY LODS | CHAMINADE | WILLIAMS | |
| DANNY | MACCHIAROLA | XAVIER | HOLY CROSS |
| NIKOLAS | MACE | HOLY TRINITY | MOUNT ST VINCENTS |
| TYLER | MARGOLIES | SACHEM EAST | MOUNT ST VINCENTS |
| TREY | MCGOWAN | BAYPORT BLUE POINT | OSWEGO |
| CAM | MCGUGAN | FITCH | NEW HAVEN |
| JAKE | MEIROWITZ | WHEATLEY | MUHLENBURG |
| CODY | MILLER | ROCKY POINT | EAST TENNESSEE |
| JOHN | MOELLER | KINGS PARK | OLD WESTBURY |
| JAKE | MOSS | MANHASSET | UPENN |
| CARMELO | MUSACCHIA | FORDHAM PREP | NORTHEASTERN |
| BEN | NOSOVITCH | CARLE PLACE | QUEENS |
| PALMER | O’BIERNE | HUNTINGTON | STATE COLLEGE OF FLORIDA |
| MICHAEL | O’SHAUGHNESSY | CHRISTIAN BROTHERS | DAVIDSON |
| ANDREW | PARK | CHAMINADE | TRINITY |
| CHRIS | PICARELLA | MACARTHUR | POST CT |
| ANTHONY | PRISINZANO | CHAMINADE | COLLEGE OF STATEN ISLAND |
| LEYTON | PULSIPHER | CENTER MORICHES | CENTRAL CONN ST |
| RANDY | RAMNARACE | ST JOHN THE BAPTIST | NEW HAVEN |
| LOGAN | ROBERSTON | BAYPORT BLUE POINT | ITHACA |
| COLIN | ROSS | WILLIAM FLOYD | STAC |
| KADE | RUFFNER | BRYANT PURDUE | |
| MATT | SANDOVAL | WEST ISLIP | ONEONTA |
| TYLER | SAUSVILLE | COLONIE CENTRAL | NEW HAVEN |
| DYLAN | SCHNITZER | HUNTINGTON | TRINITY |
| RYAN | SETTER | SMITHTOWN WEST | CMSV |
| MICHAEL | STEINBERG | SMITHTOWN WEST | MARITIME |
| DECLAN | SULLIVAN | ST ANTHONYS | HOOD |
| DEREK | TORRES | ST DOMS | STAC |
| NICHOLAS | UNGANIA | CHAMINADE | BINGHAMTON |
| JACK | VALLARIO | ST ANTHONYS | FORDHAM |
| DOM | VASSALLO | MONSIGNOR MCCLANCY | LIU |
| CHRIS | VELASQUEZ | COMSWOGUE | MARITIME |
| JOHN | VITUCCI | WAGNER | SETON HALL |
| CARSON | WENGROVSKY | ST JOHN THE BAPTIST | BELMONT ABBEY |
| 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2007 | 2008 | 2009 | 2010 | 2011 | 2012 | 2013 | 2014 | 2015 | 2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 | 2020 | 2021 | 2022 |
| First Name | Last Name | High School | College Commit |
| ANDREW | ALAMEDA | FARMINGDALE | STAC |
| MIKE | ANDERSON | BELLPORT | FARMINGDALE |
| FRANK | ASARO | WHEATLEY | MERCY |
| CHARLIE | AURANDT | BAYPORT BLUEPOINT | ST JOES LI |
| JACOB | BACENET | SWR | RUSSELL SAGE |
| JAKE | BAPTIST | NORTH BABYLON | STEVENSON |
| TEDDY | BRENNAN | SALISBURY | JAMES MADISON |
| DYLAN | BRUNO | IMG | GRAND CANYON |
| MASON | CALAFATI | KINGS PARK | STEVENSON |
| SHANE | CALLAHAN | NEWFIELD | UTICA |
| COLTRANE | CALLOWAY | BAY SHORE | SETON HALL |
| DOM | CAMERA | ST DOMINICS | GEORGE WASHINGTON |
| ANTHONY | CAPOGNA | ST ANTHONYS | SCRANTON |
| MIKE | CATRONE | NORTHPORT | PLATTSBURGH |
| FRANKIE | COLLETTA | ST JOHN THE BAPTIST | RUSSELL SAGE |
| TYLER | COONEY | LINDENHURST | HOOD |
| JUSTIN | CORDERO | SACHEM NORTH | FARMINGDALE |
| DOM | D’ALLESANDRO | NEWFIELD | ULSTER CC |
| MATT | DESTEFANO | CLARKE | STONY BROOK |
| RICH | DIAMOND | RIVERDALE COUNTRY | TUFTS |
| TOM | DIGIROLOMO | ST JOHN THE BAPTIST | BROCKPORT |
| LIAM | DOYLE | CONNETQUOT | RUSSELL SAGE |
| JOE | DURSO | KELLENBERG | ST JOHNS |
| BRANDON | ERBIS | WEST HAMPTON | SOUTHERN NEW HAMPSHIRE |
| JORDAN | FALCO | CENTER MORICHES | ADELPHI |
| RYAN | FERREMI | EAST ISLIP | ALBANY |
| ANDREW | FLOOD | MANHASSET | WASHINGTON & LEE |
| CONNOR | FOX | MATTITUCK | STEVENSON |
| MICHAEL | FREDA | HILLS WEST | QUEENS |
| JAMES | GOFF | CONNETQUOT | ADELPHI |
| JOSH | GRAHAM | SALESIAN | ST EDWARDS |
| JAMES | GRUENFELDER | PORT JEFF | HOOD |
| CAM | HEUER | HUNTER | RPI |
| DYLAN | JOHNSON | NEWFIELD | ST JOHNS |
| KYLE | JONES | LONGWOOD | PENN ST YORK |
| AJ | JOYA | CENTRAL ISLIP | ST JOES LI |
| JACK | KELLY | LINDENHURST | ST JOES LI |
| LOGAN | KOBIS | HIGH POINT REGIONAL | SUSSEX CC |
| SEAN | LANE | ST DOMINICS | MARYLAND |
| TOMMY | LEBRECHT | CHAMINADE | HOFSTRA |
| CHRIS | LEONE | HAUPPAUGE | STONY BROOK |
| JOE | LEONE | PLAINEDGE | QUEENS |
| DENNIS | LYNCH | SEAFORD | CONCORDIA |
| MATT | MARIANO | SHENENDEHOWA | ALBANY |
| COLE | MAUCERE | WEST BABYLON | NEW HAVEN |
| SEAN | MILETI | CONNETQUOT | MOLLOY |
| ANTHONY | MIFSUD | CARLE PLACE | CONCORDIA |
| ANDREW | MORAN | WEST HAMPTON | DEAN |
| MICHAEL | OLNICK | RAMAZ | EMORY |
| LUKE | ORBON | NEW HYDE PARK | ST JOHNS |
| JAVEN | PEÑA | FREEPORT | LINCOLN |
| COOPER | PRIESTLEY | XAVERIAN | ITHACA |
| ANTHONY | QUATROMANI | FARMINGDALE | ST. JOES LI |
| JT | RAAB | MACARTHUR | STONY BROOK |
| NICK | ROSELLI | DIVISON | BINGHAMTON |
| DANIEL | ROSMAN | ROSYLN | HAVERFORD |
| VIN | RUTIGLIANO | CAREY | CONCORDIA |
| DREW | SALAMY | EAST HAMPTON | OBERLIN |
| SAM | SALTZMAN | PLAINVIEW | SUNY PURCHASE |
| FRANK | SANTERAMO | GARDEN CITY | MARTIME |
| LUKE | SCHARTNER | BAYPORT BLUEPOINT | CORTLAND |
| RAFE | SCHLESINGER | SACHEM EAST | MIAMI |
| JACOB | STEINMETZ | HAFTR | FORDHAM |
| JOSUE | VALDEZ | SALESIAN | VILLANOVA |
| RYAN | VAN BUREN | ABINGTON | MARYLAND |
| TOMMY | VENTIMIGLIA | LONGWOOD | STONY BROOK |
| LONNIE | WHITE | MALVERN PREP | PENN STATE |
| TOM | WILKE | ST JOHN THE BAPTIST | DREW |
| TOMMY | YOST | PORT JEFF | FDU-FLORHAM |
| DYLAN | ZUCKER | LOCUST VALLEY | WAKE FOREST |
| 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2007 | 2008 | 2009 | 2010 | 2011 | 2012 | 2013 | 2014 | 2015 | 2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 | 2020 | 2021 | 2022 |
| 2020 Players | High School | College Commit |
| HECTOR ALEJANDRO | SACRED HEART ACAD | UCONN |
| BRADLEY BATTAGLINI | WEST ISLIP | CORTLAND |
| JULIAN BELARDO | KELLENBERG | PENN ST HARRISBURG |
| KEVIN BOWROSEN | MILLER PLACE | JAMES MADISON |
| COLE BOYAN | EASTERN PENN | ST HARRISBURG |
| MATT BROWN-EIRING | CONNETQUOT | STONY BROOK |
| JOE CAIN | SEAFORD | ST JOSEPHS LI |
| JACK CARR | THE STONY BROOK SCHOOL | STONY BROOK |
| JOHNNY CASTAGNOZZI | MASSAPEQUA | NORTH CAROLINA |
| CHRISTIAN CICCHETTI | WEST BABYLON | UTICA |
| MICHEAL CIMINIELLO | SMITHTOWN EAST | SETON HALL |
| FRANKIE COLLORA | WARD MELVILLE | CORTLAND |
| BOBBY CONLON | MASSAPEQUA | FLORIDA GULF COAST |
| FRANK COZZOLINO | SEAFORD | STAQ |
| PETER DALY | WANTAGH | FARMINGDALE |
| CHRIS DEVEAU | CARLE PLACE | PLYMOUTH |
| DANTE DIMARCO | CALHOUN | ST JOSEPHS LI |
| CHRISTIAN ELETTO | LOCUST VALLEY | UMASS BOSTON |
| ALEX FELIZ | SCHOOL OF SCIENCES | BRIDGEPORT |
| JOHNNY FLANNIGAN | ST DOMS | TRINITY |
| KENNY FRANQUIZ | MEPHAM | NEW HAVEN |
| NOAH FRASCA | ST JOHN THE BAPTIST | ONEONTA |
| TYLER GALLETTI | PLAINVIEW | SACRED HEART |
| GIANCARLO GIACOMETTI | ST JOHN THE BAPTIST | FARMINGDALE |
| JAY HAMILTON | LONG BEACH | CONCORDIA |
| ANTHONY HERNANDEZ | NEWFIELD | ST JOSEPHS BK |
| COLE HOUSER | HEMPFIELD | MILLERSVILLE |
| WILL KASPER | JERICHO | MUHLENBERG |
| SEAN KENNEDY | EAST MEADOW | ST VINCENT |
| ANDREW LEDBETTER | WALT WHITMAN | STONY BROOK |
| RYAN LEVENBERG | HAUPPAUGE | HOFSTRA |
| TOMMY LYNCH | SEAFORD | CONCORDIA |
| GAVIN MACALONIE | MILLER PLACE | MOLLOY |
| RYAN MADENBERG | GREAT NECK SOUTH | BINGHAMTON |
| ANTHONY MAROTTA | ST FRANCIS PREP | SCRANTON |
| RYAN MICHELI | SACHEM EAST | STONY BROOK |
| BOBBY MOLINARO JR | BABYLON | ADELPHI |
| ANDREW MONDA | NEWFIELD | ST JOSEPHS BK |
| TIM MOTT | HOLY TRINITY | MOLLOY |
| IAN MOURELATOS | MILLER PLACE | FARMINGDALE |
| BROCK MURTHA | SAYVILLE | NOTRE DAME |
| JUSTIN ORTIZ | ARCHBISHOP MOLLOY | NEW PLATZ |
| JOE PASQUA | ST FRANCIS PREP | ADELPHI |
| MATT PELCHER | CALHOUN | HOFSTRA |
| ANTHONY PERICOLOSI | SOUTH SIDE | HOFSTRA |
| COREY PHELAN | HARBORFIELDS | FLAGLER |
| JARED POTTER | WARD MELVILLE | MITCHELL |
| MICHEAL PRISCO | NEWFIELD | ALBANY |
| CHRIS PUPA | SEAFORD | LIU |
| JACK REARDON | COMMACK | NEW HAVEN |
| ALEX RENDE | MASSAPEQUA | ADELPHI |
| ANDREW ROMAN | NEWFIELD | POST |
| JUSTIN ROSNER | FARMINGDALE | BINGHAMTON |
| MICHEAL SADOWSKI | QUEENS METRO | ONEONTA |
| JARED SCIARRINO | SHOREHAM WADING RIVER | STAQ |
| JAI SHARMA | SMITHTOWN EAST | OSWEGO |
| SEAN TIERNEY | MACARTHUR | NASSAU CC |
| KYLE TORCIVIA | WALT WHITMAN | ADELPHI |
| ALEX UNGAR | CONNETQUOT | ALBANY |
| DOMINICK VELASQUEZ | DOVER | DELAWARE |
| MAX VIERA | RABUN GAP NOCOOCHEE | NORTHEASTERN |
| MAX WEINSTEIN | SACHEM EAST | MT ST VINCENT |
| FRANK WHITENACK | PLAINEDGE | SUNY WESTBURY |
| DON WILLE | SACHEM EAST | MONROE CC |
| JOE WOZNY | STONY BROOK SCHOOL | UCONN |
| COLE ZAFFIRO | MANHASSET | U PENN |
| 2003 | 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2007 | 2008 | 2009 | 2010 | 2011 | 2012 | 2013 | 2014 | 2015 | 2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 | 2020 | 2021 | 2022 |
| 2019 Players | High School | College Commit |
| TREVOR ADAMO | CONNETQUOT | COKER |
| CHRISTIAN AMAROUSO | SMITHTOWN WEST | LINCOLN MEMORIAL |
| DAVID AUFIERO | NORTH SHORE | SACRED HEART |
| ANDREW BIANCO | KINGS PARK | NEW HAVEN |
| ANTHONY CINQUIMANNI | WEST ISLIP | ST JOSEPHS LI |
| ANDREW CIUFO | PHILLIPS ANDOVER | GEORGETOWN |
| ZEKE CLASE | WALT WHITMAN | HERKIMER |
| TYLER COSTARO | SOUTH SIDE | ARCADIA |
| CHARLIE CUCCHIARA | EAST MEADOW | MOLLOY |
| PATRICK CULLIGIAN | CHAMINADE | SCRANTON |
| JASON DIAZ | KELLENBERG | MIAMI |
| COLIN DIEZ | DIVISION | QUEENS |
| LUCAS DIGIOVANNI | JOHN GLENN | SUNY PLATTSBURGH |
| GREG DORFMAN | MIDWOOD | DELAWARE ST |
| ROMAN DOROSH | SACHEM EAST | JACKSONVILLE |
| EJ EXPOSITO | ST JOHN THE BAPTIST | NYIT |
| DAVID FALCO | CENTER MORICHES | MARYLAND |
| TYLER GAMBA | WEST BABYLON | ST JOSEPHS LI |
| PHIL GERENA | XAVIER | LIU |
| CHANDLER GIOVINCO | NEWFIELD | HOFSTRA |
| JOE GISONDA | VALLEY STREAM NORTH | ALBANY |
| DOUG GOODWIN | SMITHTOWN EAST | BINGHAMTON |
| BRYCE GRATWOHL | MATTITUCK | VASSAR |
| PAUL GUGLIZZIO | KINGS PARK | ST JOSEPHS LI |
| JUSTIN HARVEY | SMITHTOWN EAST | SUNY NEW PALTZ |
| NICK HARVEY | SMITHTOWN EAST | SUNY NEW PALTZ |
| DANIEL HELFCOTT | DOM BOSCO PREP | NJIT |
| REED HOSKINS | BALDWIN | QUEENS |
| VINCENT IANNUZZI | SMITHTOWN WEST | ADELPHI |
| ALEX INCALATERRA | PLAINEDGE | MOLLOY |
| MATT KANYUK | HHH EAST | HERKIMER |
| WILL KENNEDY | SMITHTOWN EAST | HOFSTRA |
| LOGAN KOESTER | CHAMINADE | GEORGE WASHINGTON |
| PHIL KRPATA | FARMINGDALE | ST JOSEPHS LI |
| JACK KRENTZMAN | RIVERDALE PREP | NORTHEASTERN |
| MICHEAL LADONNA | WEST ISLIP | NYIT |
| AIDAN LARKIN | CHAMINADE | HOFSTRA |
| MATT LEWIN | NORTH SHORE | BARD |
| MICHEAL LISOGO | ST DOMNICKS ACADEMY | CONCORDIA |
| FRANCO LOGUZZO | OCEANSIDE | ST JOSEPHS LI |
| NICK LOMONICO | WILLIAM FLOYD | EAST TENN ST |
| ALEC MAAG | CENTER MORICHES | EASTERN CONN |
| CAMERON MAYER | SYOSSET | TUFTS |
| ROB MILOPSKY | ROCKY POINT | HILLSBOROUGH CC |
| DARYHL MOON | NEW HYDE PARK | WEST VIRGINIA WESLEYAN |
| MAX MOSS | BEACON | CLARK |
| LUKE NAPOLITANO | KELLENBERG | KANSAS |
| PAUL ORBON | CHAMINADE | ST JOHNS |
| CONNER PHELAN | HARBORFIELDS | ST JOSEPHS LI |
| JAKE PIERRE | SACHEM NORTH | MT ST VINCENT |
| TOMMY REIFLER | GARDEN CITY | BINGHAMTON |
| STEVEN RIZZO | ST ANTHONYS | FRANKLIN & MARSHALL |
| MICHEAL ROTHSTEIN | PLAINVIEW JFK | WEST VIRGINIA WESLEYAN |
| JOE SAVINO | CONNETQUOT | ELON |
| NICK SCHWARTZ | MASSAPEQUA | ST JOHNS |
| DEREK SHREVE | KINGS PARK | ST JOSEPHS LI |
| KOSTA SIAFAKAS | LOCUST VALLEY | CONCORDIA |
| ANDREW SILVERMAN | COMMACK | NEW HAVEN |
| MICHEAL STORMS | SMITHTOWN EAST | ADELPHI |
| JOESPH TARDINO | KINGS PARK | FARMINGDALE |
| MATT TEMPONE | SMITHTOWN EAST | U of RHODE ISLAND |
| HUNTER TRAENKLE | DIVISION | ULSTER |
| AJ VERGA | WILLIAM FLOYD | MOLLOY |
| DEREK YALON | CONNETQUOT | STONY BROOK |
| JARED YALON | CONNETQUOT | STONY BROOK |
| MATT YIPP | HERRICKS | UNC WILMINGTON |
| 2003 | 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2007 | 2008 | 2009 | 2010 | 2011 | 2012 | 2013 | 2014 | 2015 | 2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 | 2020 | 2021 | 2022 |
| 2018 Players | High School | College Commit |
| HAYDEN ALTIMARI | ST ANTHONYS | PENN ST – BRANDYWINE |
| MATT AYALA | WANTAGH | ALVERNIA |
| BRIAN BORNKAMP | PLAINEDGE | DOMINICAN |
| CHRIS BUEHLER | WARD MELVILLE | LIU BROOKLYN |
| JAMES CARDINALE | COMMACK | HOFSTRA |
| ANTHONY CARLEO | NORTH SHORE | LACKAWANNA CC |
| DJ CHANDLER | RIVERHEAD | ST. THOMAS AQUINAS |
| PAUL CHRISTOPHER | KELLENBERG | OSWEGO |
| MIKE COLE | PLAINVIEW | FRANKLIN & MARSHALL |
| MICHEAL CONWAY | MINEOLA | ADELPHI |
| JASON COULES | BELLMORE | FORDHAM |
| MICHEAL CUNNEY | WHEATLEY | ST THOMAS AQUINAS |
| ANTHONY D’ONOFRIO | WANTAGH | HOFSTRA |
| JULIAN DREW | JERICHO | OSWEGO |
| THOMAS ELETTO | LOCUST VALLEY | NEW HAVEN |
| MARK FAELLO | PLAINVIEW | HOFSTRA |
| WILL FEIL | WHEATLEY | ALBANY |
| BRIAN FITZPATRICK | ST ANTHONYS | RUTGERS |
| ANTHONY FONTANA | WANTAGH | FURMAN |
| STEPHEN GELINA | KINGS PARK | CITY COLLEGE OF NY |
| WILLIAM GILBERT | BEACON | CORNELL |
| JASON GOLDSTEIN | GREAT NECK NORTH | UNION |
| MIKE HANDAL | GARDEN CITY | FAIRFIELD |
| PATRICK HOFFMAN | EAST MEADOW | MOLLOY |
| MATT HOGAN | HILLS EAST | VANDERBILT |
| JOE JACOBS | GREAT NECK NORTH | CORTLAND |
| EDWARD JARVIS | REGIS | NORTHEASTERN |
| KYLE JOHNSON | NEWFIELD | STONY BROOK |
| JESSE KESHNER | SHOREHAM WADING RIVER | NEW PALTZ |
| BRYAN KROLIKOWSKI | ST JOHN THE BAPTIST | QUEENS |
| JOSH LESTER | COPIAGUE | NEW HAVEN |
| TYLER MARINACCIOPLAINVIEW | PLAINVIEW | MAINE |
| ETHAN MCMENAMY | HILLS WEST | MERCY |
| KEVIN MCNIFF | GARDEN CITY | NEW HAVEN |
| ANTHONY MOLINARI | CHAMINADE | QUEENS OF CHARLOTTE |
| MIKE MORENO | MASSAPEQUA | MACALESTER (MN) |
| LOGAN O’HOPPE | ST JOHN THE BAPTIST | EAST CAROLINA |
| FRANKLIN PARRA | COPIAGUE | SAN JACINTO |
| NICK PAYERO | MONROE TOWNSHIP | SETON HALL |
| JACK PELUSO | CHAMINADE | CREIGHTON |
| CHRIS PERALTA | VALLEY STREAM SOUTH | MOLLOY |
| EDDIE POPOLIZIO | HILLS WEST | CLARKSON |
| LIAM PULSIPHER | CENTER MORICHES | STONY BROOK |
| GEORGE RAINER | MT SINAI | RPI |
| COLETON REITAN | MILLER PLACE | WESLEYAN |
| JUSTIN RENNER | KELLENBERG | MOLLOY |
| MIKE RODRIGUEZ | CLARKE | NYIT |
| JORDAN ROSE | ST ANTHONYS | ST ROSE |
| DOM RUTIGLIANO | CAREY | NEW HAVEN |
| RYAN SALTZMAN | PLAINVIEW | MERCY |
| PETER SANDERSON | HAUPPAUGE | MT ST VINCENT |
| CONER SCHILDT | HAUPPAUGE | HAGERSTOWN |
| WILL SHAW | ST JOHN THE BAPTIST | JAMES MADISON |
| ALEX TOPOREK | BIRCH WATHEN LENOX | JOHN HOPKINS |
| NICK UNGAR | CONNETQUOT | OSWEGO |
| GAGE VOGEL | SMITHTOWN WEST | CITY COLLEGE OF NY |
| PATRICK WILLIX | WANTAGH | MOLLOY |
| KEVIN YOHE | ST DOMS | ST JOSEPHS LI |
| 2003 | 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2007 | 2008 | 2009 | 2010 | 2011 | 2012 | 2013 | 2014 | 2015 | 2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 | 2020 | 2021 | 2022 |
| 2017 Players | High School | College Commit |
| PAUL ARIOLA | CHAMINADE | COLBY COLLEGE |
| MATTHEW AUFIERO | CHAMINADE | SACRED HEART |
| MATTHEW BOYKO | CLARKE | NYIT |
| ROBERT BRUST | WILLIAM FLOYD | CALDWELL COLLEGE |
| BRAD CAMARDA | HHHW | HOFSTRA UNIVERSITY |
| CHRIS CAPPAS | KELLENBERG | UNIVERSITY OF PITTSBURGH |
| NICK CARDIERI | MIDWOOD | UNIVERSITY OF MAINE |
| ANDREW CHIDESTER | COMMACK | ITHACA COLLEGE |
| HARRISON COHEN | COLD SPRING HARBOR | GEORGE WASHINGTON UNIVERSITY |
| THOMAS CRISPYN | HOLY TRINITY | ST JOSEPHS |
| EJ CUMBO | CLARKE | NYIT |
| ANTONIO DEODATO | WHEATLEY | LIU POST |
| TREVOR FAGAN | WANTAGH | LIU POST |
| MATTHEW FERRARO | CHAMINADE | SCRANTON UNIVERSITY |
| KEN GORDON | BABYLON | FLAGLER UNIVERSITY |
| JOSEPH GRECO | BELLPORT | SACRED HEART |
| RYAN KARP | HOLY TRINITY | STONY BROOK UNIVERSITY |
| JONAH KATZ | KELLENBERG | COLBY COLLEGE |
| NOAH LANDOW | HHH WEST | NYU |
| BOBBY LEWIS | MACARTHUR | QUINNIPIAC UNIVERSITY |
| CHRIS LOLLO | SACHEM NORTH | WASHINGTON COLLEGE |
| JON LUPPENS | SHOREHAM WADING RIVER | SUNY OSWEGO |
| BRAD MALM | PAT-MED | UNIVERSITY OF ALBANY |
| MARK MAURELLI | NEWFIELD | STEVENS TECH |
| JAKE MCCARTHY | NORTHPORT | MOLLOY COLLEGE |
| SEAN MCGUINESS | CENTEREACH | ST ROSE COLLEGE |
| BRIAN MORRELL | SWR | NOTRE DAME |
| BRIAN MORRISEY | COMMACK | STONY BROOK UNIVERSITY |
| MATHEW MULLIGAN | BELLPORT | SUNY PURCHASE |
| MICHEAL NACINOVICH | ST FRANCIS PREP | MOLLOY COLLEGE |
| ANDREW NAGEL | GARDEN CITY | UMASS |
| LUKE O’MAHONY | MASSAPEQUA | LIU POST |
| MATTHEW OVERTON | HAUPPAUGE | MOLLOY COLLEGE |
| MICHEAL PALAZZOLO | HHHE | STONY BROOK UNIVERSITY |
| JOHNNY POHLMAN | COMMACK | ST ROSE COLLEGE |
| ERIC RUSSO | CENTEREACH | MITCHELL COLLEGE |
| JACK RYAN | JOHN GLENN | ADELPHI |
| BRENDAN RYAN | SACHEM EAST | ITHACA |
| JASON SALERNO | COMMACK | VASSAR COLLEGE |
| MATTHEW SCHMIDT | NEWFIELD | STEVENS TECH |
| MATTHEW SCHOCK | PLAINEDGE | ST JOSEPHS-PATCHOGUE |
| MICHAEL SEPE | WARD MELVILLE | SWATHMORE |
| DEAN STALZER | SWR | OSWEGO |
| MAX STEELE | MILLER PLACE | ADELPHI |
| CHRIS STEFL | FLORAL PARK | ST JOHNS UNIVERSITY |
| PETER THEODORELLIS | COMMACK | FAIRLEIGH DICKINSON |
| MICHEAL TITO | SEAFORD | CLARKSON UNIVERSITY |
| CAMERON TOMAIKO | ST ANTHONYS | UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN |
| NICK TRABACCHI | SMITHTOWN WEST | UNIVERSITY OF MARYLAND BALTIMORE COUNTY |
| GREG TSOUPRAKOS | WEST ISLIP | PACE UNIVERSITY |
| JOSEPH VALENTINO | WEST ISLIP | LIU POST |
| JAMES WEISMAN | ROCKY POINT | BROOKDALE CC |
| TYLER WIDERCRANTZ | NEWFIELD | VASSAR COLLEGE |
| 2003 | 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2007 | 2008 | 2009 | 2010 | 2011 | 2012 | 2013 | 2014 | 2015 | 2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 | 2020 | 2021 | 2022 |
| 2016 Players | High School | College Commit |
| Tristan Amone | Pat-Med | Fairfield |
| Ben Anderson | Shenendehowa | Binghamton |
| Ian Anderson | Shenendehowa | Vanderbilt |
| Julien Arcos | Chaminade | LIU Post |
| TylerArella | John Glenn | Villanova |
| Vincent Biordi | Plainedge | St. Joseph |
| Brandon Bonanno | Mt Sinai | Stony Brook |
| Justin Cancel | St Doms | Dominican |
| Grant Elgarten | Friends Academy | Middlebury |
| Brandon Fannizza | Massapequa | NYIT |
| Zach Fritz | East Meadow | LIU Post |
| Andrew Genovese | Hewlett | St Joseph |
| Nick Grande | Smithtown West | Stony Brook |
| Andrew Grieve | Sachem North | St Joseph |
| Nick Gulotta | St Doms | St Joseph |
| Matt Gutleber | Holy Cross | LIU Post |
| Chris Harbin | Patchogue | East Nazareth |
| Greg Haynes | New Hyde Park | LIU Post |
| Garrett Heaton | Bellport | Stony Brook |
| Billy Huber | Hauppauge | New Haven |
| Mike Iacobellis | Island Trees | St Joseph |
| Hunter Kaucky | Floyd | Martime |
| Shaun Kelly | Smithtown East | Cortland |
| James Kory | West Islip | St Thomas Aquinas |
| John Larocca | St Doms | Monmouth |
| Dylan Livingston | Port Washington | Monmouth |
| TJ Mcguire | Bayport | McDaniel |
| James Messina | New Hyde Park | Molloy |
| Vincent Napolitano | Garden City | LIU Post |
| Reid Oreste | Bellmore JFK | New Paltz |
| Straton Podaras | Chaminade | Radford |
| Mike Reda | St Doms | St Joseph |
| Kurt Rissland | Kellenberg | LIU Post |
| Tyler Sanderson | Hauppauge | St Joseph |
| Troy Simpson | Longwood | Adelphi |
| Mike Stiles | Comsewogue | LIU Post |
| Kyle Strovink | Rocky Point | Lamar |
| Conner Sullivan | St Doms | Catholic |
| Greg Tan | St Doms | St Joseph |
| Joe Tardiff | Mattituck | Cortland |
| Paul Twibell | Chaminade | Scranton |
| Anthony Visconte | East Islip | Cortland |
| Marc Wagenstein | Connetquot | Albany |
| Ray Weber | West Islip | Albany |
| Robert Weissheir | Kellenberg | Hofstra |
| Tim Woodford | Hauppauge | St Joseph |
| 2003 | 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2007 | 2008 | 2009 | 2010 | 2011 | 2012 | 2013 | 2014 | 2015 | 2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 | 2020 | 2021 | 2022 |
| 2015 Players | High School | College Commit |
| Matt Bartnik | Sachem East | NYIT |
| Brandon Bonomo | HHH East | Marist |
| Alex Borman | Huntington | Rowan |
| David Brehm | Connetquot | LIU-Post |
| Anthony Chiodi | Chaminade | Fordham |
| Kevin Curtis | MacArthur | Union |
| Mike Demarest | East Islip | Adelphi |
| Jake Doyle | Seaford | Vassar |
| Joe Enea | Manhasset | Kenyon |
| Christian Esposito | Schreiber | McGill |
| Nick Fanti | Hauppauge | Marist |
| Jon Faraci | HHH West | St. Johns |
| Michael Ferrufino | Island Trees | St. Joe’s |
| Joe Flynn | Ward Melville | Princeton |
| Sal Fradella | Chaminade | Villanova |
| Andrew Garcia | Pat-Med | New Haven |
| Sal Geraci | Bayport-Blue Point | LIU-Post |
| Aaron Glickstein | HHH West | Stony Brook |
| Lucas Hall | Seaford | Columbia |
| Brian Kavanagh | East Meadow | LIU-Post |
| Brandon Kustek | MacArthur | SUNY Cortland |
| Pat Lagravinese | St. John the Baptist | SUNY Albany |
| Anthony Lazar | William Floyd | Marist |
| JJ Lindgren | Newfield | SUNY Old Westbury |
| Greg Marino | Centereach | Stony Brook |
| Anthony Mammano | St. Dominics | Mercy College |
| Joey Marzouk | HHH East | Hofstra |
| Daniel McEvoy | Westhampton Beach | Stony Brook |
| Owen McMenamy | HHH West | Iona |
| Jimmy Mendyk | Plainedge | LIU-Post |
| Andrew Misiaszek | Southside | Northeastern |
| Eddie Modica | St. Anthony’s | LIU-Brooklyn |
| Nick Morena | Sachem North | Stony Brook |
| Brandon Morse | Connetquot | Adelphi |
| Chris Mott | Sachem East | Dowling |
| Andrew Mundy | St. John the Baptist | Hofstra |
| Evan Nagel | Regis | Washington U. |
| Jesse Nakashian | Massapequa | Montclair St. |
| Michael O’Brien | Plainview JFK | Concordia |
| Kevin O’Connor | Harborfields | Hofstra |
| Anthony Papa | Division | LIU-Post |
| Diego Pastrana | Division | NYIT |
| Tyler Patane | Sachem North | St. Thomas Aquinas |
| Joe Piscitelli | Division | LIU-Post |
| Anthony Raucci | Island Trees | Dowling |
| Matt Schwartz | HHH East | Vassar |
| Brandon Simone | Holy Cross | Dominican |
| Ryan Smith | Garden City | Princeton |
| Austin Tomaiko | St. Anthony’s | Navy |
| James Varela | Division | LIU-Post |
| Richie Villa | HHH East | Lafayette |
| 2003 | 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2007 | 2008 | 2009 | 2010 | 2011 | 2012 | 2013 | 2014 | 2015 | 2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 | 2020 | 2021 | 2022 |
| 2014 Players | High School | College Commit |
| Aaron Floyd | Longwood | San Jacinto JUCO (TX) |
| Michael Reilly | Hicksville | Lackawanna CC |
| Andruw Gazzola | Longwood | Stony Brook |
| Jeffrey Sarra | Connetquot | SUNY New Paltz |
| Jesse Berardi | Commack | St. Johns |
| Chris Weiss | Longwood | Hofstra |
| Jack Piekos | Bayport/Blue Point | Maryland |
| Chris Tracz | Plainview | Marist |
| Robert Calabrese | Poly Prep | University of Illinois at Chicago |
| Frank Moscatiello | Rocky Point | STAC |
| CJ Moore | Suffield Academy | Lamar University (TX) |
| Mark Martinez | Division | Lackawanna CC |
| Kyle Cashman | Hicksville | Pace |
| Joseph Spitaleri | Division | Lackawanna CC |
| Chris Reilly | Division | SUNY Farmingdale |
| Steven Foster | Sachem North | Hofstra |
| Tyler Theiss | Deer Park | Bridgeport |
| Brady Renner | St. Dominic | George Washington |
| Brandon Haffer-Vivas | Syosset | Queens College |
| Jack Laudani | Smithtown East | Delaware St. |
| Anthony Pantano | Farmingdale | SUNY New Paltz |
| Francisco Almanzar Jr. | Bethpage | Dominican |
| Robert Andreoli | MacArthur | LIU POST |
| Joseph Cacciato | Huntington | University of Tampa |
| Dominick Ciardullo | Kellenberg | Roger Williams |
| Nicholas Schoen | Hicksville | SUNY Old Westbury |
| Michael Catanzaro | Farmingdale | St. Josephs College |
| Kevin Edgar | Southampton | Keystone |
| Aaron Schiavoni | Pierson | Maritime |
| Nick Osma | St. Anthony’s | Nichols |
| Dennis Buckstein | Sachem North | Dowling |
| Camden Orologio | Longwood | Adelphi |
| Zachary Garick | Kings Park | Canisius |
| Mat Annunziata | Eastport-South Manor | Hofstra |
| Patrick Bryant | Center Moriches | Wake Forest |
| Matt Buckshaw | Connetquot | Stony Brook |
| Chris Cepeda | Ward Melville | Dowling |
| Zachary Shindler | Wantagh | College of NJ |
| Tom DiGiorgi | HHH West | St. Petersburg CC (FL) |
| Nick Garland | Massapequa | Central CT State |
| Bobby Honeyman | Massapequa | Stony Brook |
| Christian Spagnuola | Commack | R.P.I. |
| Sean Boyle | Newfield | Suffolk CC |
| Anthony Pantano | Farmingdale | SUNY New Paltz |
| Kenny Fils-Aime | North Babylon | Dowling |
| Louis Doria | Wantagh | LIU-CW Post |
| Aaron Schiavoni | Pierson | SUNY Maritime |
| Scott Hilbrandt | Farmingdale | NYU |
| Billy McLean | Wheatley | Stony Brook |
| Jack Palma | Smithtown Christian | St. Josephs College |
| Patrick Leonard | Mepham | Misericordia |
| Joe Baker | North Babylon | Dowling |
| Kevin Montefusco | Huntington | New Paltz |
| Domenic Palumbo | Plainview JFK | Nassau CC |
| 2003 | 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2007 | 2008 | 2009 | 2010 | 2011 | 2012 | 2013 | 2014 | 2015 | 2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 | 2020 | 2021 | 2022 |
| 2013 Players | High School | College Commit |
| Anthony Galanoudis | Farmingdale | Molloy College |
| Anthony Kay | Ward Melville | University of Connecticut |
| Anthony Martelli | Valley Stream North | New York Tech University |
| Billy Riedel | John Glenn | SUNY Oneonta |
| Bobby Kollmer | MacArthur | Hofstra University |
| Bobby Morse | Commack | Dowling College |
| Brad Witkowski | Lindenhurst | Hofstra University |
| Brandon Garrett | Pennsbury | University of Rhode Island |
| Brian Tinney | St. Anthony’s | C.W. Post |
| Brian Trabulsi | Chaminade | Villanova |
| Chris Gaffney | St. John the Baptist | UNC-Wilmington |
| Chris Gallic | Chaminade | Trinity |
| Chris Prete | Chaminade | Fairfield University |
| Chris Russo | William Floyd | Iona College |
| Cody Olsen | Commack | University of Connecticut |
| Connor Powers | Kellenberg | University of Rhode Island |
| Cory Blankmeyer | St. Dominics | Salve Regina University |
| Cory Hecht | Plainview JFK | Franklin & Marshall |
| Dan Caniano | Chaminade | US Military Academy |
| Dan Hetzel | Sachem East | University of Rhode Island |
| Dan Hopkins | St. Dominics | Fairfield University |
| Dan Jagiello | West Islip | C.W. Post |
| David Grossfeld | Chaminade | Tufts |
| Dom Danetti | MacArthur | Dowling College |
| Eddie Tammaro | Southside | University of New Haven |
| Greg Coman | Ward Melville | Harvard University |
| Greg Egan | St. John the Baptist | Quinnipiac University |
| Jack Zagaja | St. Dominics | University of New Haven |
| James Long | Oceanside | C.W. Post |
| Joe Booker | Port Jefferson | Franklin Pierce |
| Joe Fusco | WT Clarke | Hofstra University |
| Joe Guercio | Kings Park | SUNY Stony Brook |
| Joe Romero | Chaminade | SUNY Albany |
| Kieran Ryan | St. Dominics | Hofstra University |
| Kyle Collins | St. John the Baptist | Canisius |
| Kyle Fagan | Wantagh | C.W. Post |
| Luke Stampfl | HHH West | Fordham University |
| Matt Cafiero | St. Dominics | SUNY Oneonta |
| Matt Weissheier | Kellenberg | Hofstra University |
| Michael Ceparano | HHH East | Adelphi University |
| Michael Farley | Bayport-Blue Point | University of South Florida |
| Micheal Castiglie | Chaminade | Amherst |
| Mike Castagnaro | St. Dominics | C.W. Post |
| Nick Duarte | Schreiber | Siena |
| Nick Russo | William Floyd | University of New Haven |
| Pat Madigan | Holy Trinity | Northeastern University |
| Riley Shea | Comsewogue | University of Rhode Island |
| Rob Fiato | Huntington | New York Tech University |
| Ron Bauer | Hicksville | Molloy College |
| Stephen Woods Jr. | HHH East | SUNY Albany |
| Taso Stathopoulos | St. Francis Prep | University of Rhode Island |
| Thomas Yohe | St. Dominics | Muhlenberg College |
| Tom Joannou | Calhoun | New York Tech University |
| Troy Scocca | St. Dominics | Fairfield University |
| Vincent Aprea | Comsewogue | University of New Haven |
| Will Serviss | Rocky Point | Mt. St. Mary |
| Wyatt Schmidt | Southampton | Catholic University |
| 2003 | 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2007 | 2008 | 2009 | 2010 | 2011 | 2012 | 2013 | 2014 | 2015 | 2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 | 2020 | 2021 | 2022 |
| 2012 Players | High School | COLLEGE | |
| ALOISE | RYAN | SAYVILLE | Dowling |
| BLASBERG | SHAWN | ROCKY POINT | Suffolk CC |
| BRENNAN | KYLE | WARD MELVILLE | Buffalo |
| CHIARAMONTE | JOE | MACARTHUR | Nassau CC |
| CHOMAN | CHRISTIAN | HOLY REDEEMER | Iona |
| D’ACUNTI | MICHAEL | ST. ANTHONY’S | Temple |
| D’ONOFRIO | DAN | PATCHOGUE-MEDFORD | Suffolk CC |
| DADDINO | JOHN | CAREY | Iona |
| DEDONA | ANTHONY | BETHPAGE | Franklin Pierce |
| DEVITO | JOSEPH | HOLY TRINITY | Fordham |
| DIECKHOFF | THOMAS | SAYVILLE | New Palz |
| EGAN | GREG | ST. JOHN THE BAPTIST | Quinnipiac |
| GALIANO | CHARLES | COMMACK | Fordham |
| JEANNETTI | MICHAEL | ISLAND TREES | Pace |
| KIMBALL | BRIAN | HARBORFIELDS | Misericordia |
| KITT | CAMERON | COMMACK | Farmingdale |
| KNESNIK | TIM | Stony Brook | |
| KRAEGER | DOUGLAS | KELLENBERG MEMORIAL | Richmond |
| MAIETTA | VINNY | ST MARY’S | St. Peters |
| MCCORMICK | RYAN | MASSAPEQUA HS | St. Johns |
| MOORE | ROBERT | LONGWOOD | St. Peters |
| NAKASHIAN | JAMES | MASSAPEQUA HS | Felician |
| NUNZIATO | NICK | WARD MELVILLE | New Haven |
| O’REILLY | MIKE | SHOREHAM WADING RIVER | Flagler |
| ORSO | STEPHEN | SCHREIBER | Maryland |
| OTT | JAMES | MASSAPEQUA | Oneonta |
| PALLADINO | MICHAEL | KELLENBERG MEMORIAL | Quinnipiac |
| PALLADINO | JOHN | KELLENBERG MEMORIAL | Catholic U. |
| PATRIZIO | RICHARD | ST. ANTHONY’S | Franklin Pierce |
| RICCIO | THOMAS | COMSEWOGUE | New Haven |
| RUNCO | JOSEPH | NORTH POCONO | Fordham |
| SCHILDT | CARL “CJ” | HAUPPAUGE | Stony Brook |
| SCHULTHEIS | JOEY | BETHPAGE | Felician |
| SMITH | DAN | MILLER PLACE | Iona |
| STAFFORD | STEPHAN | PLAINVIEW HS | Iona |
| SULLIVAN | BRENDAN | ST DOMINIC | Farmingdale |
| TRIMARCO | FRANK | CALHOUN | Monmouth |
| WRIGHT | BEN | EAST MEADOW | Briarcliff |
| 2003 | 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2007 | 2008 | 2009 | 2010 | 2011 | 2012 | 2013 | 2014 | 2015 | 2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 | 2020 | 2021 | 2022 |
| 2011 PLAYERS | High School | College | |
| ABBATE | SEAN | DIVISON | MANHATTAN |
| ALESSI | RICK | SMITHTOWN WEST | U OF TAMPA |
| BARRATO | NICK | VALLEY STREAM NORTH | LIU BROOKLYN |
| BATAS | NICK | ST DOMINICS | ADELPHI |
| BRASS | MIKE | WILLIAM FLOYD | STONY BROOK |
| BUTLER | BRENDAN | SAYVILLE | FAIRLEIGH DICKINSON |
| CAMBRIA | RICH | ROCKY POINT | ADELPHI |
| CAPUTO | TIM | JOHN GLENN | UNIV RHODE ISLAND |
| CARUSO | DYLAN | SACHEM EAST | HARFORD C.C. |
| CRUZ | JOHN | DIVISON | DOWLING |
| DADDINO | JOHN | CAREY | IONA |
| DIXON | MATT | CENTEREACH | NEW PALTZ |
| FALCONI | ALEX | ST MARY’S | SETON HALL |
| GATTO | ANTHONY | SMITHTOWN WEST | UMBC |
| GENEO | ALEX | LINDENHURST | ST. THOMAS AQUINAS |
| GOLDSTEIN | STEPHEN | ST DOMINICS | STONY BROOK |
| GOING | RJ | ISLIP | FRANKLIN PIERCE |
| GOULD | CHRIS | WHEATLEY | ST. ROSE |
| GRILLO | TOM | ST DOMINICS | FLORIDA GULF COAST |
| GUILIANO | JIM | CONNETQUOT | IONA |
| HARDISON | TYLER | LONGWOOD | KEUKA |
| HEALY | CHRIS | UCONN | |
| KAUFMAN | MIKE | HALF HOLLOW HILLS EAST | BINGHAMTON |
| KASTELAN | TOM | DEER PARK | CW POST |
| LAMBROS | LOU | ST DOMINICS | IONA |
| LAURINO | STEPHEN | CARLE PLACE | MARIST |
| MANGNIELLO | MIKE | ISLAND TREES | CONCORDIA |
| MANNING | MICHAEL | NORTH BABYLON | BRIARCLIFF |
| MONTALTO | JESSE | CAREY | FAIRLEIGH DICKINSON |
| MOOSSMANN | ADAM | NORTHPORT | TRINITY |
| NESTOPOLOUS | MATT | ITHACA | CAZENOVIA |
| O’GARA | COLIN | NORTHPORT | HARTFORD |
| PARISI | DAN | LONGWOOD | CATAWBA COLLEGE |
| PERLINE | YOHNA | ST DOMINICS | FAIRLEIGH DICKINSON |
| POLICASTRO | JOE | HAUPPAUGE | MERCHANT MARIN |
| RAUCCI | DOM | ISLAND TREES | MOLLOY |
| ROEHRIG | MIKE | LINDENHURST | STONY BROOK |
| SLIWAK | RYAN | WANTAGH | STONY BROOK |
| SORGIE | CAMERON | WILLIAM FLOYD | ALBANY |
| TRACY | JOE | ST MARY’S | U ALBANY |
| VRANA | RICH | LINDENHURST | MARIST |
| WHALLEY | JUSTIN | ST. ANTHONY’S | JOHNS HOPKINS |
| WOOD | MIKE | ROCKY POINT | DOWLING |
| ZITAGLIO | ANTHONY | ROCKY POINT | ST. JOSEPHS |
| ZITO | NICK | SMITHTOWN WEST | ADELPHI |
| 2003 | 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2007 | 2008 | 2009 | 2010 | 2011 | 2012 | 2013 | 2014 | 2015 | 2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 | 2020 | 2021 | 2022 |
| 2010 PLAYERS | High School | College | |
| ABREU | ANDREW | CENTEREACH | DOWLING COLLEGE |
| ARCHBOLD | KEVIN | BELLMORE JFK | ALBANY |
| AUGUST | PETER | HOLY TRINITY | CW POST |
| BENEDETTO | MATT | WANTAGH | DOWLING COLLEGE |
| BESSELL | JJ | LONGWOOD | DOWLING COLLEGE |
| BLUMENTHAL | MIKE | HALF HOLLOW HILLS WEST | QUINNIPIAC UNIVERSITY |
| BRANDMAIER | J.C. | MEPHAM | DOWLING COLLEGE |
| BRUNETTI | ANTHONY | HOLY TRINITY | CW POST |
| BURNS | GARY | PLAINVIEW | CALDWELL COLLEGE |
| BURROWS | PETER | CHAMINADE | TRINITY |
| COURTNEY | KEVIN | ST JOHN THE BAPTIST | STONY BROOK UNIVERSITY |
| CUNNINGHAM | CASEY | CHAMINADE | ST ROSE COLLEGE |
| CACHIOLI | RYAN | ST ANTHONY’S | AMERICAN INTERNATIONAL |
| COSTELLO | ANDREW | SMITHTOWN EAST | FLAGGLER |
| D’ALESSANDRO | TOM | HALF HOLLOW HILLS EAST | CORNELL UNIVERSITY |
| D’ANGELO | NICK | MT SINAI HS | ST THOMAS AQUINAS |
| DILL | STEVEN | HAUPPAUGE HS | HARVARD |
| FASANO | JOE | SMITHTOWN WEST | NEW JERSEY INST TECH |
| FAUST | CHRISTIAN | ST ANTHONY’S | SOUTH CAROLINA UPSTATE |
| FERNANDEZ | JOE | XAVERIAN | LIU BROOKLYN |
| GALANOUDIS | JOHN | FARMINGDALE | MOLLOY |
| HANEY | BRANDON | KINGS PARK | FLAGGLER |
| HOLLANDER | MITCH | SYOSSET | BINGHAMTON |
| HUNTER | BRIAN | ST JOHN THE BAPTIST | HARTFORD |
| JACKSON | KENNY | CONNETQUOT | HOFSTRA UNIVERSITY |
| KALOUSDIAN | CHRIS | KINGS PARK | MANHATTAN |
| KAPLAN | PETER | FRIENDS ACAD. | HARVARD |
| KARALAKIS | NICK | WALT WHITMAN | CALDWELL COLLEGE |
| KELLER | EVERETT | PORT WASHINGTON | HOFSTRA UNIVERSITY |
| LEONELLO | PETER | COMMACK | LIU BROOKLYN |
| LUCZAJ | STEPHEN | MEPHAM | CALDWELL COLLEGE |
| MACALUSO | EDDIE | ISLIP | IONA |
| MARINE | ALEX | FREEPORT | ST THOMAS AQUINAS |
| MARSHALL | DOUG | MEPHAM | NEW PALTZ |
| MARTIN | MIKE | CHAMINADE | MANHATTAN |
| MASTELLONE | LOU | NORTH SHORE | SUNY BROCKPORT |
| MCGIBBON | JONATHAN | LINDENHURST | CLEMSON UNIVERSITY |
| MCQUAIL | NICHOLAS | MACARTHUR | MARIST |
| MILONE | MATT | SACHEM NORTH | SCRANTON |
| NASSAYAN | ANDREW | NEW ROCHELLE | FRANKLIN PIERCE |
| O’NEIL | TOM | ST JOHN THE BAPTIST | MT ST VINCENTS |
| PECORARO | TJ | HALF HOLLOW HILLS WEST | VANDERBILT |
| PYZ | CHRIS | KINGS PARK | NEW PALTZ |
| SCHNEIDER | IAN | MT SINAI HS | DOWLING COLLEGE |
| SHADA | MIKE | SACHEM EAST | QUEENS COLLEGE |
| TOLAN | TOM | KELLENBERG | CW POST |
| TRACY | KYLE | BETHPAGE | SUNY BROCKPORT |
| VANDERKA | FRANKIE | MACARTHUR | STONY BROOK UNIVERSITY |
| VELTRE | ROB | MASSAPEQUA | DOWLING COLLEGE |
| VERBITSKY | BRYAN | ISLAND TRESS | HOFSTRA UNIVERSITY |
| VITALANO | BOBBY | HAUPPAUGE HS | IONA |
| 2003 | 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2007 | 2008 | 2009 | 2010 | 2011 | 2012 | 2013 | 2014 | 2015 | 2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 | 2020 | 2021 | 2022 |
| 2009 PLAYERS | HIGH SCHOOL | COLLEGE | |
| CRAIG | SEAN | ROCKY POINT | Dowling |
| STEINMAN | CHARLIE | CHAMINADE | Georgetown |
| MOLLOY | JOHN | CAREY | New Paltz |
| MARRA | TOM | CHAMINADE | Holy Cross |
| CUNNINGHAM | MICHEAL | SYOSSET | New Haven |
| SANTILLO | GIANCARLO | HOLY CROSS | Manhattan |
| REMI | RONALD | ST ANTHONY’S | Farmingdale |
| MAURO | BRIAN | KELLENBERG | York |
| MISTRETTA | BRYAN | COMMACK | Cortland |
| LEONARD | KYLE | MEPHAM | Bryant |
| EPSTEIN | JORDON | PORT WASHINGTON | Post |
| PINNOLA | TOM | NORTH BABYLON | New Paltz |
| MORSE | STEVEN | COMMACK | Dowling |
| CHISMAR | CHRIS | LINDENHURST | New Paltz |
| CRAIG | PETER | ROCKY POINT | Adelphi |
| BISHOP | WALTER | KELLENBERG | Millersville |
| PIPERNO | CHRIS | MACARTHUR | Lynn |
| PRESTANO | KEITH | XAVERIAN | Chippola JUCO |
| BROWN | KEVIN | SOUTHSIDE HS | Binghamton |
| GELLING | KYLE | WEST ISLIP | George Washington |
| LAMACCHIA | DEREK | HOLY CROSS | Quinnipiac |
| GOLDBERG | BEN | PLAINVIEW JFK | Trinity |
| MCCORMICK | MATTHEW | MASSAPEQUA HS | LIU-Brooklyn |
| CEASER | VINNY | MASSAPEQUA | Stony Brook |
| ZINK | MATT | SYOSSET | Richmond |
| HALL | DAVID | COMMACK HS | Temple |
| HOWARD | THOMAS | SOUTHSIDE | Tuffs |
| WILHELM | CHRIS | CHAMINADE | Johns Hopkins |
| YERRY | GC | ONTEORA | Stony Brook |
| TESSAR | GREG | ST ANTHONY’S | Delaware |
| BROWN | ADAM | HALF HOLLOW HILLS EAST | Stony Brook |
| VALLE | MATT | HOLY CROSS | LIU-Brooklyn |
| CAMPBELL | JAMES | ST JOESPH-TRUMBELL | Stony Brook |
| QUICKER | TOM | ST JOHN THE BAPTIST | Souther New Hampshire |
| MILLER | THOR | MILLER PLACE | Stony Brook |
| SARNI | MICHEAL | SHELTON | Adelphi |
| 2003 | 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2007 | 2008 | 2009 | 2010 | 2011 | 2012 | 2013 | 2014 | 2015 | 2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 | 2020 | 2021 | 2022 |
| 2008 PLAYERS | HIGH SCHOOL | COLLEGE | DRAFT |
| Alex Aurrichio | HHH West | Columbia | |
| Ray Angelucci | Commack | Dowling | |
| Nick Alexandravich | Commack | College of St. Rose | |
| Tom Berardi | Commack | Cortland | |
| Pat Cantwell | West Islip | Stony Brook | 3rd round – Texas Rangers |
| Stephen Smith | West Islip | Niagara | |
| Nick Tropeano | West Islip | Stony Brook | 5th round – Houston Astros |
| Ryan Pfaffle | Commack | George Mason | |
| Ryan Brenner | Chaminade | Yale | |
| Rob Rodgers | Islip | Binghamton | |
| Scott Swanson | Bellmore JFK | Binghamton | |
| Jake Weshler | Harborfields | Lehigh | |
| Steven Shea | East Islip | Briarcliff | |
| Colin Lyall | Kellenberg | Iona | |
| Matt Simone | St. John the Baptist | Iona | |
| Matt Zink | Syosset | Richmond | |
| Craig Matteo | St. Mary’s | Adelphi | |
| Andrew English | Smithtown West | Dowling | |
| Chris Burke | Islip | Iona | 18th round – San Diego Padres |
| Adam Krebs | Commack | Monmouth | |
| Keith Piccoini | Chaminade | Coastal Carolina | |
| David Darcy | Island Trees | Briarcliff | |
| Dan Scanlon | Hauppauge | Suffolk CC | |
| Ethan Loosen | Kellenberg | Jacksonville | |
| Pat Fullam | St. Anthonys | Navy | |
| Andrew McKenna | Connetquot | Manhattan | |
| Matt Parker | St. Anthonys | Binghamton | |
| Philip Parker | Xaverian | New Paltz | |
| Joe Romano | Regis | Georgetown | |
| Mark Sargente | Hauppauge | Hartford | |
| Eric Herbst | East Islip | Franklin & Marshall | |
| Gavin McCullogh | Stamford (CT) | Vermont | |
| Gerald Levano | Chaminade | Boston College | |
| Sal Intagliata | Carey | Stony Brook | |
| Nick Albero | Arlington | Dowling |
| 2003 | 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2007 | 2008 | 2009 | 2010 | 2011 | 2012 | 2013 | 2014 | 2015 | 2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 | 2020 | 2021 | 2022 |
| 2007 PLAYERS | HIGH SCHOOL | COLLEGE | DRAFT |
| Kevin Alas | Chaminade | William & Mary | |
| Kyle Crean | Miller Place | Albany | |
| Bryan Russo | Clarke | UMBC | |
| Colin Barnathan | St. Anthony | Dowling | |
| Josh Feit | Pascack Hills (NJ) | Brown | |
| Eddie Squeri | William Floyd | Dowling | |
| Peter Bregartner | East Islip | Binghamton | |
| David Kubiak | Southold | Albany | 36th round – Tampa Rays |
| James Stone | Chaminade | Fordham | |
| Bo Budkevics | Deerk Park | CW Post | |
| Matt Loosen | Chaminade | Jacksonville | |
| Nick Thode | Walt Whitman | Stony Brook | |
| Maxx Catapano | Amity (CT) | UConn | 46th round – Seattle Mariners |
| Ryan Mikalsen | Sachem East | UConn | |
| Matt Colantonio | Chaminade | Brown | 22nd round – San Diego Padres |
| John Mincone | HHH East | James Madison | |
| Mike Puka | MacArthur | St. Thomas Aquinas | |
| Eric Bornstein | Oceanside | Franklin & Marshall | |
| Bryan Penalo | Monroe Woodbury | St. Joseph (PA) | |
| Sean Giblin | Pearl River | 10th round – Pittsburgh Pirates | |
| Kevin Ryan | MacArthur | St. Thomas Aquinas | |
| Roy Natoli | Southside | Central CT | |
| Ralph Tufano | St. Josephs by the Sea | Dowling | |
| Greg De Palma | MacArthur | Sacred Heart | |
| Joe Martino | Clarke | Fairleigh Dickinson | |
| Dan McDermott | MacArthur | St. Thomas Aquinas | |
| Vito Frabizio | Deer Park | New Mexico CC | |
| Angelo Montalbano | Eastport-South Manor | Suffolk CC | |
| Matt Papillo | Mepham | Cortland | |
| Kenny Wright | Longwood | Pace | |
| Mike Rubertone | Port Washington | Fairfield | |
| James Giulletti | Plainview | Binghamton | |
| Dan Illibassi | Wantagh | Flagler (FL) | |
| Mike Padavano | Chaminade | Catholic U | |
| Prateek Thaman | Hauppauge | Fairleigh Dickinson | |
| Mike Tinnery | St. Joseph by the Sea | LIU-Brooklyn | |
| Nick Compito | Syosset | Northeastern | |
| Greg Smith | Eastport-South Manor | UNC-Greensboro | |
| Dan Burawa | Rocky Point | Stony Brook | 12th round – NY Yankees |
| Eric Stampfl | St. John the Baptist | CW Post | |
| Tim Deos | Longwood | Suffolk CC | |
| Jeff Piscitelli | Hamden Hall (CT) | St. Peters |
| 2003 | 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2007 | 2008 | 2009 | 2010 | 2011 | 2012 | 2013 | 2014 | 2015 | 2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 | 2020 | 2021 | 2022 |
| 2006 PLAYERS | HIGH SCHOOL | COLLEGE | DRAFT |
| Mike Belfiore | Commack | Boston College | |
| Sal DePaola | Kellenberg | Pace | |
| Glenn Gibson | Center Moriches | Nationals- 4th Rd. | |
| Bobby Haney | Kings Park | Manatee CC (FL) | Phillies- 35th Rd. |
| Ryan Heenan | St. Anthony’s | Molloy | |
| Brian Kemp | Chaminade | St. Johns | |
| Chris Nieves | Monroe-Woodbury | Fairfield | |
| Dan Pembroke | Shoreham-Wading River | Dowling | |
| Matt Petition | Garden City | Tulane | |
| Louis Picconi | Chaminade | Penn State | |
| Matt Prokopowicz | Massapequa | Hofstra | |
| Sandy Sussman | Archbishop-Molloy | Marist | |
| Derek Squires | William Floyd | Columbia | |
| Gerald Tingos | Moore Catholic | LIU-Brooklyn | |
| Josh Valle | Brentwood | Marshall | |
| Bobby Thomas | Hicksville | Farmingdale | |
| Buddy Cipoletti | St. John the Baptist | Wagner | |
| Charlie Ellinger | Massapequa | UMBC | |
| Conor Febos | Sayville | Farmingdale | |
| Dan Smith | Sachem East | St. Joseph | |
| Dan Alaimo | Deer Park | Dowling | |
| Frank Staib | Connetquot | Adelphi | |
| Frank Ryan | Lindenhurst | NYIT | |
| Garrett Landry | Glen Cove | Claridon CC (TX) | |
| Greg DeSantis | Bridgewater (NJ) | LIU-Brooklyn | |
| Greg Gilroy | Smithtown West | NYIT | |
| Jason Intelisano | Shoreham-Wading River | Adelphi | |
| Joe Mansanello | North Babylon | Cecil CC | |
| Mike Connoly | Newfield | York | |
| Mike Kobel | Bayport-Blue Point | Farmindale | |
| Ralph Rizzo | Connetquot | Albany | |
| Vinny Block | Chaminade | Farmingdale | |
| Joe Trainor | Massapequa | Dowling | |
| Matt Katten | Plainview | Emory (GA) | |
| Mike Amendola | North Babylon | Hartford |
| 2003 | 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2007 | 2008 | 2009 | 2010 | 2011 | 2012 | 2013 | 2014 | 2015 | 2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 | 2020 | 2021 | 2022 |
| 2005 PLAYERS | HIGH SCHOOL | COLLEGE | DRAFT |
| Billy Alvino | Sachem East | High Point | |
| Pete Budkevics | Deer Park | CW Post | |
| Bryan Burke | Lindenhurst | LIU-Brooklyn | |
| John Cody | Patchogue-Medford | U. of New Orleans | |
| Ryan Craig | Rocky Point | York | |
| Nick Demeo | Sachem East | Pace | |
| Rob Difalco | Kellenberg | Hofstra | |
| Billy Dorsa | Massapequa | Iona | |
| Rob Dyer | Newfield | Stony Brook | |
| Steve Garrison | Hun School (NJ) | Brewers- 10th Rd. | |
| Jason Giani | West Islip | Marist | |
| Tom Carberry | St. Anthony’s | Binghamton | |
| Chris Gloor | Bayshore | Quinnipiac | |
| Ben Green | Plainview | Fairleigh-Dickinson | |
| Will Hassett | Chaminade | Siena | |
| Jeff Heppner | Riverhead | Vermont | |
| Matt Herrick | Patchogue-Medford | Albany | |
| Kevin Mahoney | Miller Place | Canisius | |
| Tom Marino | Chaminade | UMBC | |
| Steven Mazzurco | Newfield | Stony Brook | |
| Tom Meaney | Sachem East | UMBC | |
| Pat Miles | Kellenberg | Molloy | |
| Brian Mooney | Walt Whitman | Marshall | Blue Jays- 50th Rd. |
| Matt Monastero | Longwood | Dowling | |
| Tom O’Rourke | Glen Cove | NYIT | |
| Mike Perez | Patchogue-Medford | Iona | |
| James Schroeder | Ward Melville | Florida Southern | |
| Mike Tansey | Chaminade | Stony Brook | |
| Phil Tantillo | St. John the Baptist | Sacred Heart | |
| Ryan Walfield | Spaulding (NH) | Quinnipiac | |
| Pat Walsh | Holy Trinity | Molloy | |
| Kevin Watkins | Longwood | St. Johns | |
| Andrew Wernicki | Bethpage | Iona | |
| Josh Zeid | Amity (CT) | Tulane |
| 2003 | 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2007 | 2008 | 2009 | 2010 | 2011 | 2012 | 2013 | 2014 | 2015 | 2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 | 2020 | 2021 | 2022 |
| 2004 PLAYERS | HIGH SCHOOL | COLLEGE | DRAFT |
| Brian Alas | Chaminade | Richmond | |
| Jason Appel | Plainview | UNC-Wilmington | Phillies- 27th Rd |
| Jordon Crystal | Lindenhurst | Monmouth | |
| Rico Eaderesto | Center Moriches | Caldwell | |
| Derek Foder | Kellenberg | CW Post | |
| Scott Gaffney | Chaminade | Penn State | Red- 2007 |
| Ryan James | Shoreham-Wading River | Binghamton | |
| Brian Johnson | East Islip | Manatee CC (FL) | |
| Bret Lazar | Commack | High Point | |
| Mike Mongiello | St. John the Baptist | UNC-Greensboro | |
| David Paquette | Patchogue-Medford | Merrimack | |
| Stephen Piscitello | Hauppauge | Fairleigh Dickinson | |
| John Simone | Ward Melville | Quinnipiac |
| 2003 | 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2007 | 2008 | 2009 | 2010 | 2011 | 2012 | 2013 | 2014 | 2015 | 2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 | 2020 | 2021 | 2022 |
| 2003 PLAYERS | HIGH SCHOOL | COLLEGE | DRAFT |
| Jason Appel | UNC Wilmington | ||
| Jon Kalkau | Stony Brook | ||
| Kraig Binick | NY Tech | ||
| Mike Mongiello | UNC Greensboro | ||
| Ryan Rizzo | Quinnipiac | ||
| Dennis Donovan | UConn | ||
| Brian Pernice | Gettysburg | ||
| Tom McDermott | Mt. St. Mary’s | ||
| Paul Gibson | Quinnipiac | ||
| Bryan Cipolla | Old Dominion | ||
| Matt Lyons | Stony Brook | ||
| Ryan McArdle | Florida State | ||
| Will Devito | Hofstra | ||
| Jon Rockfeld | SUNY Cortland | ||
| Brian Walker | Hofstra | ||
| Dan Horvat | San Jacinto CC | ||
| Mike Ambort | Lamar | ||
| Pat Haughie | SUNY Binghamton |